Lisbon Village Country Club

Semi-Private,
9 hole golf course
located in Lisbon.

Why Metal Roof Repairs Fail—and How I Fix Them in Murfreesboro

I’ve spent over ten years repairing and maintaining metal roofing systems across Rutherford County, and I can say from experience that metal roofing repair service in murfreesboro is rarely about dramatic damage—it’s about small, overlooked issues that quietly turn into expensive problems. Most homeowners call me after they notice a stain or a drip, but by then the real trouble has usually been developing for years.

I started working on metal roofs early in my career, back when standing seam installations were still treated like specialty projects. I’m licensed under Tennessee requirements and have worked on everything from older exposed-fastener systems to newer concealed-clip panels. What I’ve learned is that metal roofs don’t “fail” the way shingle roofs do. They wear out in more subtle, technical ways.

One job from a couple of seasons ago still stands out. A homeowner on the outskirts of Murfreesboro called because water was showing up in a hallway after heavy rain. The roof itself was barely ten years old and looked flawless from the ground. Once I got up there, the issue became obvious: thermal movement had slowly pulled fasteners loose around a ridge transition. No rust, no missing panels—just tiny gaps that let water in under the right conditions. We tightened and replaced the affected fasteners, reset the sealing washers, and the problem disappeared. If they’d waited another year, that water would’ve reached the decking.

Metal roofs move. That’s the part many people—including some contractors—underestimate. In summer, panels expand. In winter, they contract. I’ve found that most repair failures happen because someone tried to “lock” a moving system in place with the wrong materials. I once inspected a roof where someone had filled a seam with roof cement meant for asphalt shingles. It cracked within months. By the time I saw it, water had traveled several feet beneath the panels, staining insulation far from the original seam.

Another common situation I run into involves penetrations—vents, skylights, and exhaust pipes. Last spring, I worked on a metal roof that had been leaking around a bathroom vent. The flashing itself wasn’t damaged; the sealant had simply aged out and lost elasticity. The homeowner assumed metal roofs didn’t need that kind of upkeep. That’s a misconception I hear often. Metal lasts a long time, but sealants and gaskets don’t last forever. Replacing them at the right time can extend the life of the entire roof.

I’m fairly opinionated about who should handle metal roof repairs. If someone treats metal like shingles, they’ll get short-term results at best. I’ve seen repairs done with mismatched metals that eventually caused corrosion. I’ve also seen panels screwed down too tightly, preventing movement and leading to oil-canning and seam stress. Those mistakes don’t always leak right away, which is why they’re so dangerous—they fail quietly.

One thing I always explain to homeowners is that leaks don’t always show up directly below the problem. Water can travel along seams or under panels before it finds a low point. I worked on a house where the leak showed up near an exterior wall, but the entry point was closer to the ridge. Without experience, you’d never connect the two. That’s why metal roof repair is more investigative than people expect.

I’m also honest about when a repair doesn’t make sense. Sometimes a roof has been modified too many times—extra penetrations, incompatible materials, patch-on-top-of-patch fixes. In those cases, a repair might stop the leak temporarily but won’t restore proper function. I’d rather say that upfront than offer a solution I don’t believe in.

If there’s one mistake I wish homeowners would avoid, it’s assuming that “no leak” means “no problem.” Many of the roofs I repair could’ve been kept in great shape with periodic inspections, especially after storms or extreme temperature swings. Catching a backed-out fastener or fatigued seam early is far less disruptive than tearing into finished ceilings later.

I still enjoy metal roofing repair because it rewards patience and understanding of the system. When the repair is done correctly—using compatible materials, allowing for movement, and addressing the real cause rather than the symptom—the roof performs the way it was meant to. I’ve seen properly repaired metal roofs go on for decades without further issues.

Metal roofs are resilient, but they’re not indestructible. They need someone who understands how they behave over time. After years on ladders and rooftops around Murfreesboro, I’ve learned that good repairs aren’t flashy—they’re quiet, precise, and built to move with the roof instead of fighting against it.

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *